Bored with Debian - x264 patents

25 May 2007

I am usually a strong supporter of debian, but I may change very quickly my mind…

x264

x264 was removed from debian unstable according to : http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=423250

With the very best explanation ever: Now - it contains mpeg4 stuff, try googling for “mpeg4 patent” once and you know why it needs to go out.

And with the very usefull link of http://petition.eurolinux.org/pr/pr18.html. That states: the patents that will constitute the MPEG-4 Visual Patent Portfolio License support the charging of royalties on the use of MPEG-4 Visual streams in Europe" and that a license should be available within several months.

“Should” be ? I am not an englishman, but should does not mean is. Moreover the article is from 2002 and legislation about patents has changed in Europe since that date!

Patents

Video

Video programming is filled with patents.

This so stupid than ever… Hey, Joerg Jaspert, why don’t you try “mpeg2 patent” in Google ? Oops, right ?

Then you should remove:

  • ffmpeg, libmpeg2,
  • mplayer, vlc, xine, ogle, totem, gstreamer,
  • cinelerra, avidemux…

Come on!

Other patents

What about “double-click patents” and “linux patents” in google ? It gives more answers than MPEG-4 patents… Maybe we should remove ’linux’ from debian…

Jean-Baptiste Kempf

Comments

  1. On 6 May 6060, 11:30 by Marcos Marado

    http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugr…

    http://ftp-master.debian.org/new/x2…

    The package is coming back.

  2. On 18 May 18180, 4:37 by gemtsone supplier

    Your views are very good!I very much agree with you, thank you for sharing!
    the best jewelry manufacturers in china http://www.chinajewelrysupplier.com
    <a href="http://www.chinajewelrysupplier.com" title=“jewelry supplier”>jewelry supplier
    <a href="http://www.chinajewelrysupplier.com" title=“jewelry manufacturers”>jewelry manufacturers jewelry manufacturers in china
    Your views are very good!I very much agree with you, thank you for sharing!
    gemstone supplier and gemstone wholesaler:http://www.winbowgems.com
    <a href=" http://www.winbowgems.com" title=“gemstone supplier”>gemstone supplier
    gemstone wholesaler in china http://www.winbowgems.com
    <a href=" http://www.winbowgems.com" title=“gemstone wholesale”>gemstone wholesale

  3. On 22 May 22220, 6:01 by SirCommy

    There’s nothing to wait, the answer is obvious for France. It’s upon EU

  4. On 19 May 19190, 9:28 by JBK

    @Metalhead: Well, in France too, they are forbidden. The new president is pro-patents but said he will follow European Union discussions. So, let’s wait and see.

  5. On 18 May 18180, 6:13 by MetalheadGautham

    hey JBK, I think the only reason we see x264 removed is because it is patented in the US. where I am software patents have been rejected in the parliment… how is it in France? how is the new president???

  6. On 12 May 12120, 10:14 by James

    For anyone interested in researching the patents involved, see http://www.FreePatentsOnline.com.

  7. On 27 May 27270, 11:37 by miksuh

    As I said earlier you can always use debian-multimedia.org repository. Many, if not most, Debian desktop users use that repository anyway. You could say that debian-multimedia.org is THE unofficially official multimedia repository for the Debian.

  8. On 27 May 27270, 1:31 by JBK

    @miksuh:

    I don’t think you really get my point. Everything in the multimedia field is patented with stupid patents in the U.S.

    I we start like that, we can remove everything from debian and so on.

    I am quite sure there is a patent on streaming.

  9. On 26 May 26260, 9:42 by miksuh

    “Well, you are right, but it is worse… GStreamer is architectured to be able to put external codecs… and proprietary ones…”

    So what? Those are external codecs so it’s not gstreamer problem. It’s not a problem at all if you don’t distribute codecs which have patent problems.

  10. On 26 May 26260, 9:23 by miksuh

    I don’t really understand why this is so big problem for you. I’m sure x264 will be available in the debian-multimedia.org if it is not available in official repository.

  11. On 26 May 26260, 2:25 by markit

    Completely agree. You can’t have nothing more than “hello world” that is patent-free. Btw, also “ping” is patented if you use to see if a pc is still alive.
    “non patented codecs” is almost useless, since one needs codecs to see multimedia content “as provided”. Having a ogg codec to see the last DVD I bought is useless.
    Only 2 actions to take:
    a) fight software patents and lobby to make them illegal in the unfortunate country where are accepted
    b) act like they don’t exist at all when coding/packaging.

  12. On 25 May 25250, 11:07 by JBK

    Well, you are right, but it is worse… GStreamer is architectured to be able to put external codecs… and proprietary ones…

  13. On 25 May 25250, 6:50 by Bilboed

    In fact… you can remove totem, gstreamer and any gstreamer-based application from that list. GStreamer was designed so that these kind of patent issues don’t forbid applications from using the other, non-patented, codecs.